Killer Wink

A high-energy twist on the classic game of musical chairs, complete with nerf blasters, safe zones, and the thrill of the chase. It’s musical mayhem where getting out doesn’t mean sitting out! This is an activity that is sure to bring lots of fun and laughter!

Author

Josh Barriger
April 24, 2025

Gameplay

  • 8+ Players 👥

  • 5-8 Minutes ⏱️

What You’ll Need

  • A group of players willing to be dramatic!

  • Chairs or space to sit in a circle

Setup

  • Seat the players in a circle.

  • Choose a detective and send them away from the group where they can’t see.

  • Secretly assign a killer while the detective is away. Make sure the group knows who the killer is (without pointing or speaking).

How to Play

  • Bring back the detective and start the game.

  • Let the killer kill: They do this by winking at players one by one. Victims “die” by dramatically crossing their arms or feet.

  • Watch the drama unfold: Other players may wink too, but only the killer’s wink causes a death.

  • Detective guesses: They get up to 3 guesses to identify the killer before everyone is killed.

  • Rotate roles: After each round, the killer becomes the next detective and a new killer is chosen.

Say Something Like
“Someone in this circle is a silent assassin. Can you figure out who it is before they take you all down? Keep your eyes peeled… but don’t get caught staring too long!”

Variations

  • Safe Zone Switcheroo – Switch safe zones mid-game to increase challenge.

  • Double Trouble – Two blasters, two shooters!

  • Silent Round – Players must walk in silence. Anyone talking gets an automatic nerf target on their back.

Teaching Points
This game sparks themes of hidden motives, discernment, and trust—great conversation starters about spiritual awareness and choosing who to follow.

This game idea was sent in by Josh Barriger. If you want to support him, head over and buy him a coffee!

Want access to another FREE newsletter? This one features a hub of online resources for pastors, church leaders and ministry workers–tips and tools! Check it out below!

Ministry DepotMinistry Depot is a premier online resource for pastors, church leaders, and ministry workers.

Keywords: killer wink, detective game, youth group icebreaker, circle game, sneaky game, indoor group activity

Transparency: This site is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com. We are compensated for referring traffic and business to Amazon and other companies linked to on this site.